If you need assistance, please call 724-503-0014

# Why Paying Too Much Could Be a Risk When Your Real Estate Agent Works with Just Anyone

Monday, June 2, 2025   /   by Sharon St Clair

# Why Paying Too Much Could Be a Risk When Your Real Estate Agent Works with Just Anyone

Buying or selling a home is a big deal, and having the right real estate agent makes all the difference. In areas like Cranberry Township, Peters Township, Upper St. Clair, Mt. Lebanon, and Bethel Park, a good agent can help you find the perfect fit, whether you’re a first-time homebuyer, an upsizer, a downsizer, or an investor. But what happens when your agent isn’t entirely focused on your best interests? Let’s examine why being underserved by your agent can be costly.


## The Problem: Double-Dipping and Conflicts of Interest


In real estate, “double-dipping” means one agent represents both the buyer and the seller. This allows the agent to keep the entire commission, but it’s controversial and can lead to a conflict of interest. Agents in these situations might not be as focused on what is best for you, the client, as they should be.


Here’s why this is a problem:


- Potential for Poor Representation: If an agent tries to keep both parties happy, they might not work as hard for you.

- Higher Costs: Agents might encourage you to offer more than you should, leading to unnecessarily higher expenses.

- Limited Negotiation Power: If an agent tries to please both sides, they might not negotiate as effectively for you.


A survey found that 26% of agents think double-dipping is unacceptable, while 32% see it as undesirable. This highlights the moral concerns many have with this practice. Note: We don't practice dual agency.


## The Agitation: Real-World Impacts


Double-dipping can hurt you financially. It often leads to situations where:


- You Overpay: Agents might push you to increase your offer, leading to spending more money than needed.

- Limited Trust: When an agent isn’t entirely on your side, it can feel like you don’t have someone who truly has your back.

- Increased Risk: Without dedicated representation, you might miss out on better deals or overlook crucial issues with the property.


For those buying or selling in Peters Township or other parts of the Pittsburgh area, this can mean missing opportunities or overextending budgets.


Why this matters for you:


- Buying a Home: First-time buyers might feel overwhelmed if they don’t have an agent dedicated exclusively to them. They need someone who understands their needs and budget.

Selling Your Home: Sellers want to get the best price, but a distracted agent might not market their homes as effectively.

- Making an Investment: Investors need precise data and reliable advice, which might be lacking if an agent is not fully dedicated.


## The Solution: Choosing the Right Agent


Having an agent who is focused on you and does not have split interests ensures better representation. Agents who avoid double-dipping can provide genuine advice and prioritize your needs.


Here’s how you can ensure you’re appropriately served:


1. Hire a Dedicated Agent:

   - Ensure your agent is committed to you and does not represent both parties in a deal. This removes conflicts and ensures your interests are a priority.


2. Understand Commission Structures:

   - Know how your agent is getting paid. An agent working just for you has more reason to strive for the best deal.


3. Ask for Referrals:

   - Talk to friends or family who have bought or sold homes in your desired area. They can recommend agents they trust.


4. Look for Experience:

   - In Pittsburgh, having a local expert who knows the market trends in places like Upper St. Clair or Mt. Lebanon can save you time and money.


5. Be Direct in Communication:

   - Ask your agent directly if they are representing both sides. Open dialogue ensures there is no misunderstanding.


## The Importance of Proper Representation


Being properly served means getting the full worth of what you pay for in a real estate agent. Here’s why it matters:


- For First-Time Buyers: Proper guidance ensures you find affordable options without overextending yourself.

- For Sellers: A dedicated agent means your home is marketed correctly for the best price.

- For Investors: Getting accurate and reliable information helps make wise investment choices.

- For Upsizers or Downsizers: You want an agent who understands what you are looking for in a new home, whether it’s more space or a cozy nest.


## Potential Outcomes With a Dedicated Agent


When you have an agent who is focused on just you, you’ll find that:


- Offers are More Informed: You make offers based on thorough and accurate market analysis.

- Negotiations are Stronger: An agent devoted to you will be tougher in negotiations, securing better terms.

- Decisions are More Confident: With all the correct information, you make decisions that suit your needs best.


## Final Thoughts: Choosing Right in Pittsburgh’s Market


In places like Cranberry Township or Peters Township, the right agent can make your home-buying or selling adventure smooth and successful. Trust an agent focused entirely on your best interests to ensure you’re properly served. Avoid the risks of double-dipping and ensure your choices lead to the outcomes you want.


Finding your perfect fit in the vibrant Pittsburgh market is much easier when you have the proper representation. Don’t let being underserved cost you more than it should—choose wisely and invest in peace of mind.
Marshall | St. Clair Group of Keller Williams
Sharon St Clair
395 Valley Brook Road
McMurray, PA, PA 15317
724-503-0014
7249419400151


Information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.
This site powered by CINC: www.cincpro.com