Could Pittsburgh’s Housing Market Be Good for Sellers and Buyers at the Same Time?

In 2025, Pittsburgh’s housing market is buzzing with activity that interests buyers and sellers. With its rich history, friendly neighborhoods, and diverse living options, Pittsburgh provides unique opportunities in areas like Cranberry Township, Peters Township, Upper St Clair, and Mt. Lebanon. But what’s driving the market dynamics this year? Let’s have a look at what’s happening!

---

The Problem: What Are the Challenges in Pittsburgh’s Housing Market?

Pittsburgh faces challenges that affect both buyers and sellers in 2025.

• The U.S. housing market has dealt with affordability and mortgage rates.
• Sellers find it tricky as the median sales price has decreased by 1.3% year-over-year to $225,000, while median list prices went up by 10.7% to $249,000.

Here’s what stands out:

• Diverging Prices: As list prices increase, buyer expectations might not match seller hopes. This confusion makes it harder to agree on sale prices.
• Inventory Challenges: New listings are down by 8.4%, showing that homeowners are reluctant to sell at current prices.

Why Is This a Challenge?

These price trends can be confusing and might dampen sales activity. Sellers may not want to list homes if they believe prices should be higher. Meanwhile, buyers can feel overwhelmed by prices that seem out of reach.

---

The Agitation: How Do These Issues Impact Buyers and Sellers?

Both sides are feeling the effect:

• Home Buyers: With only 1,257 homes sold—a decline of 3.8%—the market feels tight. Buyers face high prices and fewer choices, making it essential to act fast if they spot a home they like.
• Home Sellers: Sellers are also feeling challenged. While total inventory rose by 1.1%, meaning there are 5,646 homes on the market, a 20% increase in months of supply to 4.5 months suggests a more balanced market. Sellers must adjust to meet buyer expectations.

What Does This Mean for Buyers?

Buyers, especially first-time homebuyers, may need to explore various neighborhoods to find a perfect fit. They should consider:

• Emerging Areas: Areas like East Liberty or the Strip District see more investment and offer opportunities for buyers wanting a vibrant community.
• Financial Strategies: Buyers may need to set realistic budgets and look for homes with lower prices per square foot, which rose by 7.8% to $158.98.

What Does This Mean for Sellers?

Sellers should consider the current market dynamics. Price drops have risen by 0.9% to 21.1%, so pricing homes correctly is crucial.

• Competitive Pricing: Sellers must stay competitive by offering fair prices and considering current buyer affordability.
• Improving Home Appeal: Enhancing curb appeal and minor upgrades can make homes more attractive.

---

The Solution: How Can Buyers and Sellers Navigate the Pittsburgh Market?

Both buyers and sellers need a proactive approach:

Buyers

1. Interest Rates: Buyers should watch interest rates. Though expected to hover around 6-7%, they must act quickly to secure rates.
2. Neighborhood Focus: Seek areas with potential growth. Mixed-use projects in neighborhoods like Upper Lawrenceville are attractive to families and young adults.

Sellers

1. Market Trends: Sellers can take advantage of the steady appreciation in some neighborhoods, such as Mt. Lebanon. This stability can help them meet their pricing goals.
2. Marketing Strategy: Employing virtual tours and harnessing technology can engage more buyers and highlight key features of properties.

Investors

For those investing, Pittsburgh presents exciting opportunities:

Rising Demand: Areas with school quality and accessibility, such as Peters Township, are appealing and offer good return prospects.